top of page

Why Has My Cholesterol Gone Back Up? 7 Possible Reasons

Writer: The Cholesterol Coach
The Cholesterol Coach
11 minutes ago
8 min read
Woman with short grey hair and glasses using a laptop at home, illustrating someone reviewing information about their cholesterol and heart health.

You've worked hard to lower your cholesterol. You've made changes to your diet, become more active and felt delighted when your repeat blood test showed that your efforts were paying off.


But a few months later, you have another cholesterol test, only to discover that your levels have started creeping back up again.


Understandably, you're confused.


Why has my cholesterol gone back up when I'm still eating healthily?


The answer isn't always straightforward. Cholesterol levels can change for several reasons, including hormonal changes, underlying medical conditions, medication changes and normal variation between blood tests.


Let's explore seven reasons your cholesterol might have increased and what you can do about it.


1. Your cholesterol-lowering habits have gradually drifted


One of the most common frustrations I hear from people who have previously lowered their cholesterol is that they feel they're still doing everything they were doing before.


And they may well be!


But there's an important difference between doing the same types of things and doing them with the same frequency, quantity and consistency.


This is where a concept called behavioural drift comes in.


Behavioural drift describes the gradual, often unnoticed changes to our everyday behaviours over time.


Imagine you've spent three months making a conscious effort to lower your cholesterol.


You've started eating porridge every morning, swapped foods high in saturated fat for healthier alternatives, incorporated more beans and lentils into your meals and become more physically active.


Three months later, your cholesterol has come down.


Naturally, you're delighted.


You feel reassured that what you're doing is working, but some of that initial focus on your cholesterol starts to fade.


Life gets busy, circumstances change, and your routines gradually adapt.


Six months later, you have another blood test and your cholesterol has increased.


You feel frustrated because you're still eating healthily.


But if you compare a typical week now with one from those initial three months, you might notice a few subtle differences.


Perhaps:

  • The porridge you were having every morning is now something you eat two or three times a week.

  • The small sprinkling of cheese on your meals has gradually become a generous handful.

  • The beans and lentils you were regularly adding to meals aren't making it into your shopping trolley quite so often.

  • The plant sterol or stanol yoghurt drink you were having daily is something you now frequently forget.

  • The takeaway you were having once a fortnight has become a weekly tradition.

  • The evening walks you were going on have become less frequent.


None of these changes necessarily seems particularly significant in isolation.


And none of them means that you've suddenly adopted an unhealthy lifestyle.


But collectively, they may have reduced the cholesterol-lowering impact of your previous habits.


Nothing MUCH has changed, but enough may have changed to make a difference.


2. You're still eating healthily, but not getting the same cholesterol-lowering benefits


This is an important distinction.


Eating a generally healthy, balanced diet and eating a diet that actively targets cholesterol reduction aren't necessarily the same thing.


There is considerable overlap, of course, but certain dietary components have more direct cholesterol-lowering effects than others.


These include:

  • Replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats: Swapping foods rich in saturated fat for sources of unsaturated fat can help lower LDL cholesterol.

  • Beta-glucan from oats and barley: Consuming around 3g of beta-glucan daily can help lower cholesterol.

  • Plant sterols and stanols: Consuming approximately 1.5–3g daily can reduce cholesterol absorption in the gut and lower LDL cholesterol.

  • Soya protein: Incorporating soya foods can contribute to a cholesterol-lowering dietary pattern.

  • Nuts: Regularly including nuts in place of less heart-healthy foods can support cholesterol management.


And importantly, how much and how often you consume these foods influences the benefit you receive.


I often talk about the cumulative benefits of combining several evidence-based dietary changes, rather than relying on one particular food. it's the combination of different changes that can produce a meaningful reduction in LDL cholesterol.


But the reverse can also be true.


If several of those changes gradually become less consistent, you may lose some of the cholesterol-lowering benefit you were previously achieving.


You may still be eating a healthy diet, but it might not be having quite the same effect on your cholesterol.


3. Your saturated fat intake has gradually increased


Saturated fat is one of the most important dietary factors influencing LDL cholesterol.


And it's surprisingly easy for our intake to increase without us making any particularly dramatic changes to what we're eating.


Perhaps you're adding a little more cheese to meals.


Perhaps you're using butter more frequently.


Perhaps your portions of chocolate, pastries or other foods high in saturated fat have gradually increased.


Or perhaps you're eating out more often, where the amount of saturated fat in a meal can be harder to judge.


These changes don't necessarily mean you're eating badly.


But if you're someone whose LDL cholesterol is particularly responsive to saturated fat intake, relatively modest changes may make a difference.


For people actively trying to lower LDL cholesterol, aiming to keep saturated fat below around 7% of total daily energy intake can be a useful target.


Practical tip: If your cholesterol has increased, try reviewing your saturated fat intake over a few typical days. You may spot some small changes that have gradually crept in.





4. Hormonal changes, particularly menopause, may be affecting your cholesterol


Not every increase in cholesterol can be explained by a change in lifestyle.


For women, the menopause transition is a particularly important consideration.


Oestrogen influences how the body processes cholesterol, and declining oestrogen levels are associated with changes in lipid metabolism.


As a result, LDL cholesterol often increases during and after the menopause.


This means you might be maintaining a very similar diet and exercise routine but still notice your cholesterol levels rising.


Changes in body fat distribution, particularly an increase in abdominal fat, can also contribute to changes in cardiovascular and metabolic health during this stage of life.


The important message here is that a rise in cholesterol around menopause doesn't necessarily mean your healthy habits aren't working.


They may still be providing significant benefits, even if your blood results aren't moving in the direction you'd hoped.


However, it may mean that your cholesterol management needs to be reviewed, taking into account your overall cardiovascular risk and whether additional lifestyle changes or medication could be beneficial.


5. Changes in weight, activity or other lifestyle factors


Our daily routines can influence several aspects of our cardiovascular health.


For example, changes in body weight, physical activity, alcohol consumption and smoking status can affect lipid levels.


However, it's important to understand that these factors don't all influence cholesterol in the same way.


Regular physical activity often has a relatively modest direct effect on LDL cholesterol, but it can improve triglyceride levels, insulin sensitivity, blood pressure and overall cardiovascular health.


Similarly, weight loss can improve several cardiovascular risk factors, particularly in people carrying excess body fat, but the effect on LDL cholesterol varies.


And alcohol tends to have a more significant influence on triglycerides than LDL cholesterol.


So, if your LDL cholesterol has increased, it isn't necessarily because you've stopped exercising as much or gained a little weight.


Nevertheless, changes in your wider lifestyle are worth considering as part of the overall picture.


6. An underlying medical condition or medication change


Sometimes cholesterol levels increase for reasons unrelated to dietary habits.


An underactive thyroid, for example, can cause LDL cholesterol to rise.


Certain kidney and liver conditions, as well as some medications, can also influence lipid levels.


And if you've recently started, stopped or changed the dose of a cholesterol-lowering medication, this may explain why your results have changed.


It's also worth remembering that genetics plays a major role in determining cholesterol levels.


Some people have an inherited tendency towards higher LDL cholesterol, meaning lifestyle changes alone may not be sufficient to achieve their recommended targets.


If your cholesterol has increased significantly or unexpectedly, it's important to discuss your results with your GP or another appropriate healthcare professional.


They can help determine whether any additional investigations or changes to your treatment are needed.


7. Normal variation between cholesterol blood tests


Finally, it's worth remembering that cholesterol levels aren't completely static.


They can fluctuate between blood tests due to normal biological variation, differences in testing methods and other factors.


For example, results from a finger-prick test may not be directly comparable with those from a laboratory venous blood sample.


A small change in your cholesterol result doesn't necessarily mean that your cardiovascular risk has meaningfully increased or that your lifestyle changes have stopped working.


What matters is the wider picture, including which cholesterol measurements have changed, the size of that change and whether the pattern persists over time.


This is why it's important to interpret cholesterol results in context rather than focusing too heavily on a single number.


What should you do if your cholesterol has gone back up?


If you've previously lowered your cholesterol but have noticed that it's increasing again, there are a few practical steps you can take.


1. Review your results with your healthcare professional


First, make sure you understand which cholesterol measurements have increased.


Total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, non-HDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol and triglycerides provide different information.


An increase in total cholesterol doesn't always mean the same thing as an increase in LDL cholesterol.


Your GP or healthcare professional can help interpret the changes in the context of your individual cardiovascular risk, medication and medical history.


2. Compare your current habits with when your cholesterol was lower


Rather than immediately making lots of changes, spend a little time reflecting on what you were doing when your cholesterol was improving.


  • What did your typical breakfast look like?

  • How often were you eating oats, beans, lentils and other fibre-rich foods?

  • What were your main sources of saturated fat?

  • Were you consistently including specific cholesterol-lowering foods?

  • How often were you eating out?

  • And how does all of that compare with your habits today?


If you have old meal plans, food diaries or shopping lists, these can be particularly helpful.


You might notice differences that weren't immediately obvious.


3. Understand why your habits may have changed


Perhaps your working hours have changed.


Perhaps you've been dealing with additional stress or family responsibilities.


Perhaps you've stopped enjoying some of the meals you were previously having.


Or perhaps you simply stopped paying quite so much attention to your habits once you'd achieved your initial goal.


Understanding why something has changed makes it much easier to find a realistic solution.


4. Focus on one or two manageable adjustments


You don't necessarily need to overhaul your entire lifestyle to get back on track.


Perhaps you could start having porridge more regularly.


Perhaps you could increase the beans and lentils in your meals.


Perhaps you could revisit your saturated fat intake and identify a few simple swaps.


Or perhaps you could find more convenient ways to incorporate heart-healthy foods into your current routine.


The aim isn't to return to doing everything perfectly. It's to identify the changes most likely to make a difference and find ways to make them sustainable.


5. Make your habits work for your life now


This is particularly important.


The circumstances in which you originally lowered your cholesterol might be quite different from the circumstances you're living in today.


And that's OK.


Perhaps you no longer have time to prepare the same lunches.


Perhaps your working patterns have changed.


Perhaps an injury or health condition has affected your ability to exercise.


Rather than trying to force your old routine into your current circumstances, think about how you can adapt those habits.


You don't necessarily need to recreate your old routine in order to recreate some of its benefits.


Need help lowering your cholesterol and keeping it low?


This is a large part of why I created my 12-Week Heart-Healthy Living Course.


I didn't want to create a programme that simply told people what to eat for 12 weeks.


I wanted to give people the knowledge, skills and practical tools to understand their cholesterol, make meaningful lifestyle changes and maintain those habits long after the initial programme.


Alongside evidence-based education on nutrition, exercise and cholesterol management, there's a strong emphasis on mindset, behaviour change and long-term consistency.


Because knowing what to do is one thing.


Being able to put that knowledge into practice, amongst all the complexities of everyday life, is another thing entirely.





Long-term success isn't about never drifting. It's about knowing how to find your way back.


Dr Kirstyn Norman

Cholesterol & Heart Health Coach


This article provides general educational information and isn't a substitute for personalised medical advice. Always discuss unexpected changes in your cholesterol results or medication with an appropriate healthcare professional.



Comments


You Don’t Have to Figure This Out Alone

Whether you need simple recipe inspiration, a step-by-step framework, or personalised guidance, there’s a level of support to suit you.

Get my weekly emails

One email a week from me, with tips, recipes, new podcast episodes and course news. No miracle supplements, I promise.

© 2026 by The Cholesterol Coach. All rights reserved.

bottom of page